Warning: Spoilers for Beetlejuice 2 ahead!Jeremy was not at all who he pretended to be when he first met Astrid in Beetlejuice 2, and a clever detail surrounding Lydia hid his true identity. Arthur Conti’s Jeremy was one of the new characters in Beetlejuice 2 alongside Jenna Ortega, who played Lydia’s teenage daughter Astrid. At first, it seemed like Jeremy would be an innocent love interest for the youngest member of the Deetz family, but that was not the case. Jeremy turned out to be a ghost that tricked Astrid into nearly swapping her life for his.