Heretic directors Scott Beck and Bryan Woods talk about their plans for a sequel and prequels. The A24 religious horror movie stars Hugh Grant as the sinister Mr. Reed, who invites two young missionaries, played by Yellowjackets‘ Sophie Thatcher and The Fabelmans‘ Chloe East, for a game of religion on a stormy night. Heretic has received high praise among critics and audiences, currently holding a 93% approval rating from the former on Rotten Tomatoes.