Even as the latest installments have reinvigorated the series, Matthew Lillard admits to having one gripe with the new Scream movies. Lillard starred in the franchise-launching original as Stu Macher, one of the two teens revealed to be the Ghostface killer, though was defeated and seemingly killed in that movie’s ending. Though the franchise has seemingly moved beyond him, Lillard has always remained hopeful to make a Scream return, expressing that Stu survived his climactic fight with Neve Campbell’s Sidney Prescott.