Welcome to Plathville star Moriah Plath has a penchant for bad boys that isn’t so good for her, and she had painful breakups with Matthew Craven and Max Kallschmidt, but the first “cut” was the deepest. When Max broke Moriah’s heart, she wasn’t used to that kind of pain. She trusted Max (who didn’t seem like a bad boy) completely. He was so clean-cut, so seemingly devoted. Max was someone who was actually accepted by his parents. In the end, despite his wholesome image, he cheated on her, leaving her sad and hopeless. Then, she tried, as Yusef (Cat) sang: